Citizenship for Sale: What Are Your Thoughts on Price-Based Immigration System?

Australian Citizenship for Sale


  On various news channels, it was reported that the Australian government was considering “selling” the right to immigrate to Australia. The Productivity Commission was reportedly investigating a price-based immigration system. If this “radical” proposal was approved, migrants would no longer be accepted based on their family connections or skills. Instead, entry fees would be used as the primary determinant in choosing who would be granted entry to Australia.   According to news reports, this scheme could bring in tens of billions of dollars in extra revenue and could possibly help the Australian government rein in the budget deficit. It would also allow the Government to reduce the number of public servants running Australia’s immigration system.  

Opposition to the Proposed System

  Unsurprisingly, this scheme did not sit well with business groups and union. They asserted that the main focus of Australia’s immigration policy should be tackling skills shortages. Meanwhile, ethnic community groups held that they would “oppose any moves that would prevent poorer immigrants from re-uniting with their families.”  

Current vs. Proposed Immigration System

  Currently, the Australian migration policy grants permanent residency visas to three streams of migrants, namely those with relatives in Australia, those with specific skills and those who meet special eligibility criteria.   With the proposed fee-based system, the Productivity Commission studied two options to introduce the immigration fee: 1) “setting a price, with the size of the intake dictated by demand” or 2) “setting a cap on the intake and allowing demand to dictate the price of entry.”  

What are the differences?

 Immigration System Comparison

Loan Programs for Hopeful Immigrants

  Loan programs might be introduced to address the dilemma of hopeful immigrants who are unable to pay upfront. Immigrants might also be given the option to borrow against their future expected earnings.  

Not Government Policy

  Immigration Minister Peter Dutton remarked that the proposal was not government policy.   “The government is keen to see the Productivity Commission analyse these issues thoroughly, however there are no plans to make significant changes to the migration program,” he stated.  

The Impact of Fee-Based Immigration to Filipino Migrants

  It’s unquestionable that if ratified the fee-based immigration system would have great impact on Filipinos who have plans of migrating to Australia. For numerous Filipinos, the current fees for visa processing and other related expenses are already high enough as they are. Many Filipinos toil day and night to be able to come up with the necessary amount. Some even take up loans just to be able to cover the cost of migrating to Australia.   If this proposed fee-based system is passed, I fear that entry to Australia would become limited to Filipinos who belong to the upper middle class and the upper class. This would also pose a problem for Filipinos who will be married to Australian nationals, as their marriage would no longer guarantee them access to Australia, through a partner visa.   What do you think about the proposed fee-based immigration system? Tell us what you think! Leave a comment below!       References:

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *