Afritada, Kaldereta, Mechado, Menudo….Aren’t They All The Same?

Not too long ago, there was a topic trending on social media, something about a confession that would revoke your Filipino card. The answers, as you can imagine, were pretty varied and rather amusing, actually.


Quite a few admitted to disliking Adobo, Lumpia, or other such Filipino delicacies. Some mentioned difficulties in counting beyond twenty in the vernacular. (Dude, join the club.)


Now, however, it seems that we’re all collectively guilty of lacking a basic piece of information. Just last week, there was a fierce debate over what appears to be a national issue. And no, I don’t mean the ongoing dispute about our territorial boundaries. (Though it helps to read up on that too.)


I’m talking about the differences between Afritada,Kaldereta, Mechado, and Menudo.




When I mentioned this topic to our head, even he admitted to seeing them all as Menudo. I mean, aren’t they all the same tomato-based stew?


Well, no, but you wouldn’t be the first to think that.


For starters, all four of them are classified as Spanish stews – or cocidos, to be more precise. These stews typically contain your standard vegetables and meat, such as beef, chicken, pork, or even goat.


Then there’s the same blessed stock flavoring all Filipino variations of the cocidos – tomato sauce.


So, when you see a bunch of meat and vegetables stewing in a vivid red broth, you’ll probably be hard-pressed to identify it correctly. (Or you’d be too hungry to care.)


Key Differences


Here’s the thing, your choice of meat and vegetables actually makes a difference in making one of these stews. How? Let’s unpack each dish and find out:

Afritada, Kaldereta, Mechado, Menudo Infographic  
  1. Afritada is traditionally made with bone-in chicken pieces. It contains the holy trinity of stewing vegetables (potatoes, carrots, and bell peppers), so it’s practically a gateway dish in Filipino cooking. Some cooks also add green peas for color.
  3. Strictly speaking, Kaldereta should only feature goat’s meat. If you use beef, then you can’t call it Kaldereta anymore. (More like Baka-reta, get it? Never mind.)


    Furthermore, this stew has the thickest sauce among the four. This is because chicken liver is typically added to it, although you can also substitute cheese or even peanut butter for this purpose.

  5. Mechado” means “larded” in Spanish, so it only makes sense that a bit of pork loin fat often enriches this stew. Beef or pork figure heavily here, along with the usual potatoes and carrots.


    String beans can occasionally make an appearance too, and a few spoonfuls of soy sauce lend the tomato broth a savory kick.

  7. Menudo is probably the easiest to identify on sight, what with the uniformity of its ingredients. Cubed pork, cubed hotdogs, cubed potatoes, and cubed carrots (see what I mean?) are all typical of this tomato-based stew.


    Fancy a bit of sweetness? Feel free to throw in some raisins.


Happy Cooking! Don’t forget the extra rice!

Serena Estrella

Serena joined Remit back in 2016, and has tormented its Marketing Head constantly ever since. To get through the rigors of writing about grave concerns like exchange rates, citizenship requirements, and PH-AU news, she likes to blast Mozart, Vivaldi, ONE OK ROCK, and Shigeru Umebayashi in the background. She does a mean Merida voice in her spare time too.


Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *